Skip to content

Local figure

Jesse Hargrave

Jesse Hargrave came to Chapel Hill from Davidson County in 1835 and became one of the village's leading merchants, with a general store on Franklin Street by 1840. The village Methodists, who had no church, met in the room over his store. In 1843 he married Margaret Barbee, a granddaughter of one of the university's land donors. He died in 1854, and his clerks David McCauley and Thomas A. Long took over the business.

Source: Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle (Kemp Plummer), 1831-1919. History of the University of North Carolina. Volume…

Orange County Indexed has not yet linked an indexed work directly to Jesse Hargrave. The biography and the dated events on this page provide sources about Jesse Hargrave’s life and work. Suggest a source.

Life and Orange County connections

Storylines this person is part of, in date order. Each opens its own page, with its events date by date.

StorylineChapel Hill's town government and its codes, 1829–18591829–1859 · 17 events · Chapel Hill's early town codes governed its streets and policed its Black residents, enslaved and free. On February 19, 1829 the commissioners adopted fifteen ordinances that divided white men into patrol companies, made white and Black men liable to work the streets, and barred enslaved people from the streets on Sundays and at night without a written pass. An act of 1851 incorporated the town under five elected commissioners. A revised code of March 19, 1859 fixed the village limits at about 839 acres, ordered officers to check the status of Black residents who claimed to be free, and barred Black people from the country from the streets after 4 p.m. on tax and election days. StorylineChapel Hill's congregations build their churches, 1840–18591840–1859 · 17 events · Between 1842 and 1859 Chapel Hill's Episcopalians, Presbyterians, Methodists and Baptists built churches in the village, with enslaved people among the builders and the worshippers. From about 1843 the Methodists met above Jesse Hargrave's store in a room Charles F. Deems named Bethesda. People William Mercer Green enslaved worked on the Episcopal church, consecrated as the Chapel of the Holy Cross in 1848 with a wooden gallery for enslaved worshippers. The Presbyterians dedicated a small church in 1849 and the Methodists their first church in 1853. A Baptist branch of Mount Carmel opened its brick meeting house in 1855, and its first baptisms were of five people enslaved by William Barbee. In 1859 the Presbyterians installed their first pastor.

Dated events connected with this person, in date order. See these 7 dated events in the chronology →

  1. Dr. Charles R. Yancey builds a house and farm buildings on Franklin Street Dr. Yancey bought most of Lot #8 from William McCauley and put up a large house with a barn, carriage house, smokehouse, separate kitchen and quarters for enslaved people. Jesse Hargrave bought the place in 1840; the house burned in 1866. People: Jesse Hargrave Place: Yancey house (later Hargrave house), Lot #8, Franklin Street, Chapel Hill · Also named: Charles R. Yancey, William McCauleySearch the index · Bernard Lee Bryant Jr., Occupants and Structures of Franklin Street, Chapel Hill (1998; Chapel Hill Historical Society, 1999), scan p. 51
  2. Jesse Hargrave opens a general store whose upstairs room serves the Methodists Jesse Hargrave, in Chapel Hill since 1835, had a general store on Franklin Street by 1840, and bought the Yancey house the same year. In the 1840s (from about 1843) the Methodists, who had first met in Miles Davis's house, used the store's upstairs room, a former Masonic hall that Charles Deems named Bethesda. People: Jesse Hargrave Place: Hargrave's store, Franklin Street, Chapel Hill · Also mentions: Franklin StreetSearch the index · Bernard Lee Bryant Jr., Occupants and Structures of Franklin Street, Chapel Hill (1998; Chapel Hill Historical Society, 1999), scan p. 75
  3. Charles F. Deems preaches to Chapel Hill Methodists in the hall he names Bethesda While a professor, Deems preached to the village Methodists, at their invitation, in the upper story of Jesse Hargrave's store, a former Masonic lodge room he named Bethesda. After he left the university in 1848, ministers were regularly appointed to the Chapel Hill charge. People: Charles F. Deems, Jesse Hargrave Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, Volume I
  4. The General Assembly passes an act incorporating Chapel Hill under five commissioners Chapter 330 of the 1850-51 session laws, ratified January 29, 1851, made Manuel Fetter, Jesse Hargrave, Patterson H. McDade, Elisha Mitchell and Jones Watson the commissioners of Chapel Hill, with five commissioners to be elected each February after. They were to choose a magistrate of police, treasurer, constable and clerk and fix the town's bounds. People: Elisha Mitchell, Jones Watson, Manuel Fetter, Jesse Hargrave, Patterson H. McDade Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Laws of the State of North Carolina, session of 1850-51 (1851), chapter 330, pp. 730-731 · Also: Lefler and Wager, Orange County, 1752-1952; The Daily Tar Heel, October 12, 1993, p. 18
  5. David McCauley and Thomas A. Long take over Jesse Hargrave's store After Hargrave's death, his business was sold to the two young clerks he had hired in 1850. McCauley and Long's general store appears on the maps through 1868. People: Jesse Hargrave, David McCauley Place: McCauley & Long store, East Franklin Street, Chapel Hill · Also named: Thomas A. LongSearch the index · Bernard Lee Bryant Jr., Occupants and Structures of Franklin Street, Chapel Hill (1998; Chapel Hill Historical Society, 1999), scan p. 99
  6. Fire destroys the Hargrave house on Franklin Street The large house Dr. Charles Yancey built in 1822, owned by the Hargraves since 1840, burned. Jesse Hargrave's children Molly and Fred stayed on the lot in a much smaller building facing the street. People: Jesse Hargrave Place: Hargrave house (old Yancey house), East Franklin Street, Chapel HillSearch the index · Bernard Lee Bryant Jr., Occupants and Structures of Franklin Street, Chapel Hill (1998; Chapel Hill Historical Society, 1999), scan p. 115
  7. Chapel Hill merchant Thomas A. Long dies Thomas A. Long, who came to Chapel Hill as a boy to clerk for Jesse Hargrave, later kept store with David McCauley and then with Norwood, died at forty-five and was buried after services at the Methodist church on June 23. He had been a Methodist class leader, Sunday school worker and steward. People: David McCauley, Jesse Hargrave Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: Thomas A. LongSearch the index · The Chapel Hill Ledger, June 28, 1879, p. 3

Places in this person’s story

Buildings, schools, churches and other sites named in the dated events on this page, the most often named first. The map shows them all.

Map tiles © OpenStreetMap contributors. Site locations from the N.C. State Historic Preservation Office survey, Open Orange, Orange County GIS, OpenStreetMap and a few other published sources named on each site’s page; town and community pins show approximate locations.

All places and the county map →

People named in the same events

People named in the same dated entries as Jesse Hargrave, those sharing the most entries first. Each line links one of the shared entries in the chronology, where its source is cited. A shared entry shows these people in the same event, not how well they knew each other.

Research sources

Sources and research tools for this person. For ready-made searches of other catalogs, see Search further. Research guide: Trace a family through historical records.

Background

Records of the time

Collections and databases

  • NC LIVE: prepared search for Jesse Hargrave Library card Search NC LIVE for this subject and Orange County. You can change the search terms. Sign in through your North Carolina library to access the materials.
  • Ancestry Library Edition In the libraryOrange County Public Library Census, birth, death and marriage records, and more, free on the public computers at OCPL libraries

Local help

Search further

Search other catalogs and collections for this name. Results may include other people with the same name and have not been reviewed by the Friends.

Books about Jesse Hargrave

Find copies at other libraries

Photographs, papers, and newspapers

Historical records and collections

These searches use Jesse Hargrave’s name without birth or death dates, so results may include namesakes. Links open in a new tab.

Found a book OCPL doesn’t own? You can often borrow it through interlibrary loan at OCPL.

More to discover

Keep Reading Local

The Friends connect people with new library materials, local writers and publishers, and resources documenting Orange County.

Two mice reading back to back against a leaf, with the hand-lettered words Friends of the Orange County Public Library
Illustration by Caldecott Medalist Matthew Cordell, gifted to the Friends 2026