Skip to content

Storyline · 1799–1819

Student disorder and the trustees' discipline, 1799–1819

In its first twenty years the University's students repeatedly defied its faculty and trustees, and the board answered with expulsions, new ordinances and in 1817 the courts. Students beat principal Gillaspie in 1799, about forty-five left in 1805 over an oath for monitors, an 1811 outbreak left no graduates, and in 1816 a forbidden oration brought expulsions and a powder bomb at a tutor's door. Duels, a stabbing at the 1804 ball and an 1818 beating of an enslaved man ran alongside, until in 1819 students had to hand in six pistols and two dirks.

1799–1819 Filed under UNC & Campus Life 15 dated events

Title page of the Laws of the University of North-Carolina, adopted by the trustees in December 1799
Title page of the Laws of the University of North-Carolina, adopted by the trustees in December 1799Laws of the University of North-Carolina, Raleigh: J. Gales, 1800; Internet Archive · Public domain · Source

In the term before the 1799 commencement students beat principal Gillaspie, waylaid and stoned tutor William E. Webb and threatened Joseph Caldwell and Archibald Murphey, and exercises stopped for a week. Three leaders were dismissed, the faculty offered to resign, and by November Caldwell was chosen again to head the university. Complaints about the food at Steward's Hall had helped fuel the uprising, and in 1801 steward Pleasant Henderson's house was stoned. After a duel in the spring of 1803 Samuel G. Hopkins was expelled for fighting and John H. Hawkins for acting as second, and the trustees ordered that anyone in a duel be expelled and handed to the civil authorities. At the 1804 commencement ball Hyder Ally Davie stabbed Henry Chambers of Salisbury in the neck with a penknife, and the trustees, among them William R. Davie and William Polk, tried the case in the chapel the next day.

In 1805 a trustees' law made student monitors swear to report every breach of the rules. About forty-five students signed a remonstrance and left, and on September 3 Henderson wrote to trustee Walter Alves urging the board to act. The board repealed the law unanimously in December, but few of the seceders came back. In 1807 the trustees barred anyone expelled from another college and sent the ordinance to every college president in the country. In 1808 the faculty suspended John R. Stokes and Elias Foord for refusing to sign a milder version of a petition over the commons food. After an outbreak in 1811 every senior but John A. Ramsey forfeited his diploma, and the commencement conferred only an honorary A.B. on him.

In January 1814, after night raids on President Chapman's stable, cart and gate, Caldwell asked justice Pleasant Henderson for a general warrant; refused, he named five students, and a hearing questioned the student body under oath. On September 18, 1816 senior William B. Shepard spoke Republican passages Chapman had struck from his oration, students backed him, and the trustees expelled Shepard and George C. Dromgoole. In October someone left a brass door knob filled with powder at tutor John Patterson's door; a student dropped it moments before it went off, and no one was hurt. In December 1817 the trustees ordered the faculty to prosecute the offenders in the courts for "the late outrages on the buildings of the University & grove." In September 1818 three drunken students broke into a village kitchen, beat an enslaved man there and insulted the man who held him and his family, and were suspended for four months. In February 1819, after Walker Anderson's Washington's Birthday oration, a dinner ended in fighting and a peacemaker was stabbed in the arm, and the students had to hand in six pistols and two dirks.

Towns
Chapel Hill
Sites
1
People with pages
12

The events, date by date

Every statement above comes from these dated entries in the chronology. Each links to its source.

  1. Students rise against the faculty and beat principal Gillaspie In the term before the 1799 commencement students beat Gillaspie, waylaid and stoned tutor William E. Webb and threatened Caldwell and Archibald Murphey, and for a week exercises stopped. Three leaders were dismissed and the faculty offered to resign, and by that November Caldwell was chosen again to head the university. People: Joseph Caldwell, Archibald D. Murphey Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: James Smiley Gillaspie, William Edwards Webb, November CaldwellSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 155
  2. Students stone steward Pleasant Henderson's house Complaints about the food at Steward's Hall under stewards John Taylor and Pleasant Henderson helped fuel the student uprising of 1799. In 1801 Henderson's house was stoned, and he did not reapply for the stewardship. People: Pleasant Henderson Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: John Taylor · Also mentions: Steward's HallSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Steward's Hall
  3. A student duel brings expulsions and a trustee order against dueling Quarrels in the spring of 1803 led to challenges and at least one meeting. Samuel G. Hopkins was expelled for fighting and John H. Hawkins for acting as second, and the trustees ordered that anyone in a duel be expelled and handed to the civil authorities. People: Joseph Caldwell, William Polk, Samuel Hopkins Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: John H. HawkinsSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 198
  4. A quarrel at the 1804 commencement ball ends in a stabbing and a trial before the trustees At the commencement ball in Steward's Hall, Hyder Ally Davie twice trod on the toes of Henry Chambers of Salisbury while dancing. Outside, Chambers struck him and Davie stabbed Chambers in the neck with a penknife. The trustees, among them William R. Davie and William Polk, tried the case in the chapel the next day. People: William Richardson Davie, William Polk Place: Steward's Hall, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill · Also named: Hyder Ally Davie, Henry ChambersSearch the index · William Hooper, Fifty Years Since: An Address Delivered before the Alumni of the University of North-Carolina (1859), scan p. 17 · Also: Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I
  5. Pleasant Henderson writes to trustee Walter Alves about a student secession at the university Pleasant Henderson wrote to Walter Alves that about 45 students had left the university in protest over the trustees' rule requiring student monitors to take an oath, and urged Alves and the board to act. People: Walter Alves, Pleasant Henderson Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Letter from Major Henderson to Walter Alves, September 3, 1805
  6. Trustees repeal the monitor ordinance that set off the student secession The 1805 law made student monitors swear to report every breach of the rules, and forty-five students signed a remonstrance and left when it was only softened. The board repealed it unanimously in December, but few of the seceders came back. People: Archibald D. Murphey, Duncan Cameron, William Polk Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 204
  7. Trustees bar students expelled from other colleges An ordinance sent to every college president in the country refused admission to anyone expelled from another college or who had left it to avoid trial, and required applicants to declare they had not. Colleges were asked to exchange lists of expelled students. People: Benjamin Williams Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 214
  8. Thirty-eight students petition the faculty over food at Steward's Hall Signers including John Branch complained of too little butter and of beef often unsound and full of vermin. The faculty found the wording defiant and had it rewritten, and suspended John R. Stokes and Elias Foord for refusing to sign the milder version. Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: John Branch, John R. Stokes, Elias FoordSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 215
  9. A student outbreak leaves the university with no graduates After an insubordination whose details are lost, every senior except John A. Ramsey forfeited his diploma, and the 1811 commencement conferred only an honorary A.B. on Ramsey. Three of the six who later passed examinations received diplomas in 1813. Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: John Ambrose RamseySearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 188
  10. Caldwell takes students before a justice of the peace over attacks on President Chapman's property After night raids on Chapman's stable, cart and gate, and tar and feathers on his gatepost, Caldwell asked justice Pleasant Henderson for a general warrant. Refused, he named five students, and a hearing questioned the student body under oath. People: Joseph Caldwell, Pleasant Henderson, Robert Hett Chapman Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 233
  11. Senior William B. Shepard speaks forbidden political passages and sets off a student revolt Chapman had struck Republican passages from Shepard's oration and ordered him to sit when he spoke them anyway, but students cheered him on and the next day met in the chapel to back him. The trustees expelled Shepard and George C. Dromgoole, others were suspended, and most of the rest signed apologies. People: Robert Hett Chapman Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: William Biddle Shepard, George C. DromgooleSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 235
  12. A gunpowder bomb explodes outside tutor John Patterson's door Apparently in revenge for the Shepard suspensions, someone filled a brass door knob with powder, lit a match fuse and left it at Patterson's door. A student picked it up and dropped it moments before it went off, and no one was hurt. People: William Mercer Green Place: Chapel Hill · Also named: John PattersonSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 237
Show all 15 dated events
  1. Trustees order the faculty to prosecute students for damage to the buildings and grove Angered by "the late outrages on the buildings of the University & grove," the trustees ordered the faculty to prosecute the offenders in the courts. Place: Chapel Hill, University of North CarolinaSearch the index · Internet Archive: North Carolina Historical Review 29 (1952), p. 200
  2. Drunken students break into a Chapel Hill kitchen and beat an enslaved man On a Sunday three students full of corn whiskey shouted through the village, broke into a kitchen, beat a Black man there and insulted his owner and family. They were suspended for four months. Place: Chapel HillDocumenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 262
  3. Students give up pistols and dirks after a Washington's Birthday brawl After Walker Anderson's oration a dinner ended in drunken fighting, a dirk was drawn and a peacemaker was stabbed in the arm. The students were made to hand in their weapons, six pistols and two dirks, to be held while they remained at the university. People: Walker Anderson Place: Chapel HillSearch the index · Documenting the American South: Kemp P. Battle, History of the University of North Carolina, vol. I (1907), p. 263

Places in this storyline

Buildings, schools, churches and other sites named in the dated events on this page, the most often named first. The map shows them all.

Map tiles © OpenStreetMap contributors. Site locations from the N.C. State Historic Preservation Office survey, Open Orange, Orange County GIS, OpenStreetMap and a few other published sources named on each site’s page; town and community pins show approximate locations.

  • Steward’s Hall University buildings and grounds · Chapel Hill · 3 events here

All places and the county map →

People in this storyline

People with a page of their own whom the dated events above name, those named most often first.

Reading on the places and people in this storyline

No indexed work is about this storyline itself yet. These are about the sites and people its dated events name, those named most often first, so they may discuss the storyline only in part. Follow a link to find a copy or view the material.

About Joseph Caldwell · named in 3 of this story’s entries

A meeting of the citizens of Hillsborough was held on Friday the 30th instant, to adopt resolutions expressive of their feelings on occasion of the death of the late Rev. Dr. Caldwell, president of the university.

1835

Resolutions adopted by a meeting of Hillsborough citizens on Friday 30 January 1835, on the death of Joseph Caldwell, president of the University of North Carolina, who died that year. Signed at the end by W. J. Bingham as secretary and dated 31 January 1835. Printed at Hillsborough, it is a single sheet of civic mourning from Orange County.

UNC

University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Morehead Planetarium and Science Center

North Carolina ECHO (Project) · 2002

Exhibit text on Joseph Caldwell, founder of the Caldwell Observatory at UNC and the university's first president, photographed at the Morehead Planetarium on 30 May 2002 for the North Carolina ECHO project.

NC Digital Collections record courtesy of the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources.

The two Caldwell monuments on the campus of the University of North Carolina

Battle, Kemp P. (Kemp Plummer), 1831-1919 · 1902

Kemp P. Battle's 1902 account of the two monuments to Joseph Caldwell, the university's first president, on the Chapel Hill campus. Battle lived from 1831 to 1919. Detached from the December 1902 University of North Carolina Magazine and signed by Battle, it was published by the Dialectic and Philanthropic Literary Societies.

Oration on the life and character of the Rev. Jos. Caldwell, D.D. late president of the University of North Carolina : delivered at the request of the executive committee, before the trustees, the faculty and the students in Person Hall, on the 24th of June, 1835

Anderson, Walker, 1801-1857 · 1835

Walker Anderson's oration on Joseph Caldwell, the University of North Carolina's first president, given in Person Hall on 24 June 1835 before the trustees, faculty and students at the executive committee's request. J. Gales and Son printed it in Raleigh the same year.

About Pleasant Henderson · named in 3 of this story’s entries

Plan of the Village of Chapel Hill on a scale of 200 yards to an Inch--Copy from a Plot in the Possession of William Pannill which was taken from the Plot of John Craig, Esq.

1817

Hand-drawn plan of the village of Chapel Hill in 1817 at 200 yards to the inch, copied from a plot owned by William Pannill that was itself taken from John Craig's survey. It locates the University of North Carolina and names neighboring landowners, among them Joseph Caldwell, William Hooper, Pleasant Henderson and James Hogg.

Henderson, Major Pleasant: photographs (Chapel Hill Historical Society)

Photograph of a drawn likeness of Major Pleasant Henderson, the first steward of the University of North Carolina, undated. From the UNC Faculty and Administration binder in the Chapel Hill Historical Society's Prints and Photographs Collection.

About William Polk · named in 3 of this story’s entries

Senate Joint Resolutions (August 12-19)

North Carolina. General Assembly · 1778

Joint resolutions of the North Carolina Senate from 12 to 19 August 1778, 47 images. They include setting up a Board of Auditors, paying Thomas Owen, a rejected plan to let county courts call out militia against Tories, and leave for Col. Ebenezer Folson to sell public guns. Hillsborough figures in the session's business.

NC Digital Collections record courtesy of the North Carolina Department of Natural and Cultural Resources.

About Archibald D. Murphey · named in 2 of this story’s entries

Memoir of Hon. Archibald D. Murphey : late a judge of the Superior Court of North Carolina

Graham, William A. (William Alexander), 1804-1875 · 1860 · Dialectic and Philanthropic Societies

A memoir of Archibald D. Murphey, late a judge of the Superior Court of North Carolina, who died in 1832. William A. Graham wrote it, and the Dialectic and Philanthropic Societies published it at Chapel Hill in 1860 after it appeared in the August number of the North Carolina University Magazine.

UNC

Archibald Debow Murphey (1777-1832) Papers

Murphey, Archibald D. (Archibald De Bow), 1777-1832 · 1797

Papers of Archibald D. Murphey, the Orange County lawyer, state senator, superior court judge and historian, 1797 to 1852. Many of the letters are ones William Henry Hoyt gathered for his two-volume edition of Murphey's papers, published in Raleigh in 1914. Topics include court cases, internal improvements, the western lands, the university trustees, and friends in Louisiana and the Mississippi Territory in 1811 and 1812. State Archives of North Carolina, PC.12.

Miscellaneous Collection

State Archives of North Carolina. Private Manuscripts Archivists · 1689

The State Archives' Miscellaneous Collection: letters, deeds, land grants, surveys, wills, leases and other single items dating from 1689 to 2017, some as photocopies or transcripts from other repositories. Writers and subjects vary widely, governors and generals among them, and Orange County figures among the many places touched.

Wider background: UNC & Campus Life · the most widely held histories of the theme this storyline is filed under; they may not discuss it

Carolina Basketball: A Century of Excellence

Lucas, Adam · 2010 · University of North Carolina Press

Adam Lucas marks one hundred years of basketball at the University of North Carolina in this illustrated history, published by UNC Press in 2010 in association with the athletics department. Chapters follow the program from the game's arrival on campus and the 'White Phantoms' of the Southern Conference through the founding of the ACC, the 1957 season, Dean Smith's changes to the game and the title seasons of 1982, 1993, 2005 and 2009, closing with a century of statistics. 289 pages.

The Blue Divide: Duke, North Carolina, and the Battle on Tobacco Road

Moore, Johnny; Chansky, Art · 2014 · Triumph Books

The Duke and North Carolina basketball rivalry written together by Johnny Moore and Art Chansky, the latter a sports reporter who has followed it since his student days at UNC. The book opens with the 2014 season and moves through recruiting battles old and new, 'Black and Blue Sunday', 'Blood and Roses', and chapters on the rivalry's heroes, leaders and teachers, with a foreword by Jay Bilas and a photo gallery. Published by Triumph Books in 2014, 289 pages.

Miss Mary's Money

Jones, H. G. · 2014 · McFarland & Co.

H. G. Jones follows the fortune of Mary Ruffin Smith (1814-1885), the unmarried heiress whose Orange and Chatham County lands passed at her death to the University of North Carolina and the Episcopal Church. Chapters profile her grandfather Francis Jones, then trace the bequest through a quarrel among Episcopalians over Price Creek, the Chapel of the Cross and the university's buildings. A December 1885 New York Times report called the gift money; Jones shows it was land. Published by McFarland in 2014, 231 pages.

The Chronicles of the Bicentennial Observance of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Tepper, Steven J. · 1998

Steven J. Tepper's chronicle of how the University of North Carolina marked its bicentennial in 1993 and 1994. An appendix reprints the University Day speeches of October 12, 1993, given by Paul Hardin, James B. Hunt Jr., C.D. Spangler, William C. Friday, Charles Kuralt and President Bill Clinton, plus bicentennial addresses by Li Lu, Francis S. Collins and Richard J. Richardson. Published by the university in Chapel Hill, 1998; 284 pages.

Show 6 more

William Friday

Link, William A. · 1995

Biography of William C. Friday, president of the University of North Carolina system, by historian William A. Link, published by UNC Press in 1995 with the subtitle power, purpose, and American higher education. It covers Friday's career and the history of the university at Chapel Hill and statewide. Part of the Rebecca B. Wall Local History Collection.

Chapel Hill in Plain Sight

Athas, Daphne · 2010 · Eno Publishers

Twelve essays by novelist Daphne Athas (1923-2020) on the Chapel Hill she knew across the twentieth century. Subjects include Carrboro as 'the Paris of the Piedmont', philosopher Horace Williams, Betty Smith writing in Chapel Hill, Junius Scales, Ab Abernethy and the Intimate Bookshop, Richard Wright's visit, and a set of Chapel Hill murders. Published 2010, 243 pages with illustrations.

What it means to be a Tar Heel: Roy Williams and North Carolina's greatest players

Fowler, Scott · 2010 · Triumph Books

Scott Fowler gathers recollections from Carolina basketball players, decade by decade from the 1950s to the 2000s, organized around Roy Williams and the question in the title. Contributors include Lennie Rosenbluth, Larry Brown, Billy Cunningham, Charlie Scott, Phil Ford, James Worthy, Brad Daugherty, Eric Montross, Vince Carter, Antawn Jamison, Raymond Felton and Sean May, each entry giving position and playing years. Published 2010 by Triumph Books of Chicago, 270 pages, here as an e-book.

The Campus of the First State University

Henderson, Archibald · 1949

Archibald Henderson's history of the campus of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, its buildings and grounds from the founding in the 1790s onward. Henderson, a professor of mathematics and a prolific historian of the university, wrote it in the years around the university's sesquicentennial. Published by the University of North Carolina Press in 1949, 412 pages with illustrations and bibliographical footnotes.

Reviewed in The Journal of Southern History (1949), South Atlantic Quarterly (1950).

The Woman Who Rang the Bell: The Story of Cornelia Spencer Phillips

Russell, Charles Phillips · 1949

Charles Phillips Russell's biography of Cornelia Phillips Spencer (1825-1908), the Chapel Hill writer remembered for ringing the bell of South Building when the university reopened in 1875 after its closure during Reconstruction. It doubles as a history of Chapel Hill and the university. Published by the University of North Carolina Press in 1949, 293 pages with illustrations.

Reviewed in Journal of American History (1949).

Research this storyline

Each dated event above names its source, the place to start. For finding more on an event across newspapers, records and histories, see the research guide Follow an event across several accounts. Ask at the North Carolina Room of the Orange County Public Library for help with local sources.

Cite or share

Friends of the Orange County Public Library. “Student disorder and the trustees' discipline, 1799–1819.” Orange County Indexed, https://focplnc.org/orange-county-books/storylines/student-disorder-storyline-1799/. Accessed October 22, 2026.

How to cite what you find

Suggest a correction or a source →

See these events in the full chronology All storylines

Two mice reading back to back against a leaf, with the hand-lettered words Friends of the Orange County Public Library
Illustration by Caldecott Medalist Matthew Cordell, gifted to the Friends 2026