Skip to content

Storyline · 1989–1992

On the Hill and the clubs that followed, 1989–1992

On the Hill, a dance club above Four Corners on East Franklin Street, began enforcing a dress code in September 1989 that a former bouncer said was meant to keep out gay men. Protests followed, and Student Congress called for a boycott. Club Zen opened in the space in 1990 with no dress code. In 1991 the owner of The Club said his lease was ended over his gay and Black patrons, which the building owner denied.

1989–1992 Filed under LGBTQ+ Life & Activism 6 dated events

In May 1989 On the Hill, a dance club open to those 18 and older, opened in the space above Four Corners on East Franklin Street that the Down Under club had used. On September 26 its bouncers were told to enforce an unwritten dress code that a former bouncer said was meant to keep out gay men and people in alternative dress. After protests and fliers calling for a boycott, the code was not enforced on October 3. By October 10 the bar had posted a written code barring black clothing; the owner said bouncers would turn away people who dressed 'differently,' and the manager said the codes were for business reasons, not to exclude homosexuals. On November 1 Student Congress voted 20 to 1 for a resolution urging the University community not to patronize the club, whose code its sponsors said was unevenly enforced. The Panhellenic Council backed the boycott, and Town Council member Joe Herzenberg said a similar town resolution might follow.

On the Hill closed in 1989, and on January 12, 1990 Club Zen opened in its space at 175 East Franklin Street under a new owner and format, with no dress code and no restrictions on entry. By September 12, 1991 the owner of The Club, a dance club above the Four Corners restaurant, said the building's owner would not renew his lease because he objected to the club's many gay and Black patrons; the building owner denied it and called it a business decision. Herzenberg, whom the Daily Tar Heel called the first openly gay elected official in North Carolina, called the matter an abomination. The Club closed when its lease was not renewed, and the chairman of the Carolina Gay and Lesbian Association called the decision discriminatory. In June 1992 the Last Call bar opened upstairs on East Franklin Street in The Club's former space.

Towns
Chapel Hill

The events, date by date

Every statement above comes from these dated entries in the chronology. Each links to its source.

  1. On the Hill, a dance club open to those 18 and older, opens above Four Corners On the Hill opened in the space above Four Corners on East Franklin Street that the Down Under club had used, playing alternative dance music and admitting customers under 21 with stamped hands. Place: 175 1/2 E. Franklin St., Chapel Hill · Also mentions: On the Hill, East Franklin StreetSearch the index · The Daily Tar Heel, August 29, 1989, p. 17
  2. On the Hill dance bar's dress code draws charges that it targets gay patrons On the Hill, a downtown Chapel Hill dance bar, told its bouncers on September 26 to enforce an unwritten dress code that a former bouncer said was meant to keep out gay men and people in alternative dress; after protests and fliers calling for a boycott, the code was not enforced on October 3. By October 10 the bar had posted a written code barring black clothing, and owner John Hopkins said bouncers would turn away people who dressed 'differently,' while manager Sheila Brown said the codes were for business reasons, not to exclude homosexuals. Place: On the Hill, downtown Chapel Hill · Also named: John Hopkins, Sheila BrownSearch the index · The Daily Tar Heel, October 5, 1989, p. 1
  3. Student Congress calls for a boycott of the On the Hill nightclub over a dress code aimed at gay patrons Student Congress voted 20-1 for a resolution urging the University community not to patronize On the Hill, a downtown dance bar whose dress code, enforced since September, a former employee said was meant to keep out gay people and those wearing black or "alternative" clothes. Sponsors Mindy Friedman and Sam Bagenstos said the code was unevenly enforced; the Panhellenic Council backed the boycott and council member Joe Herzenberg said a similar town resolution might follow. Place: On the Hill, Franklin Street, Chapel Hill · Also named: Mindy Friedman, Sam Bagenstos, Joe HerzenbergSearch the index · The Daily Tar Heel, November 2, 1989, p. 3
  4. Club Zen opens on East Franklin Street in the former On the Hill club The dance club Club Zen opened at 175 East Franklin Street in the space of On the Hill, which had closed in 1989 after a boycott over a dress code that customers said was meant to keep gay men out; under a new owner and format, Club Zen set no dress code and no restrictions on entry. Place: 175 East Franklin Street, Chapel Hill · Also mentions: On the HillSearch the index · The Daily Tar Heel, September 7, 1990, p. 3
  5. A Franklin Street nightclub owner says his lease was ended over gay and Black patrons By September 12, 1991, the owner of The Club, a dance club above the Four Corners restaurant on Franklin Street, said the building's owner would not renew his lease in January because he objected to the club's many gay and Black patrons; the building owner denied it, the Daily Tar Heel reported, and called it a business decision. Town Council member Joe Herzenberg, the first openly gay elected official in North Carolina, called the matter an abomination. Place: Above Four Corners restaurant, Franklin Street, Chapel Hill · Also named: Joe Herzenberg · Also mentions: Franklin StreetSearch the index · The Daily Tar Heel, September 12, 1991, p. 1
  6. The Last Call bar opens upstairs on East Franklin Street where The Club had been The Last Call bar opened above Ye Olde Waffle Shoppe on East Franklin Street in the space of The Club, an alternative dance club popular with gay students and residents that closed in fall 1991 when the building's owner would not renew its lease; the Carolina Gay and Lesbian Association chairman called that decision discriminatory. Place: East Franklin Street, Chapel HillSearch the index · The Daily Tar Heel, June 4, 1992, p. 4

Further reading

No indexed work is about this storyline itself yet. These are the most widely held histories of the theme it is filed under, so they may not discuss it. Follow a link to find a copy or view the material.

Background on LGBTQ+ Life & Activism · the most widely held histories of the theme this storyline is filed under; they may not discuss it

Jane Crow: The Life of Pauli Murray

Rosenberg, Rosalind · 2017

Rosalind Rosenberg's 2017 biography of Pauli Murray (1910-1985), lawyer, poet and Episcopal priest, raised in Durham. Its six parts follow a Southern childhood, the move to New York, the 1938 application to the University of North Carolina that was refused because Murray was Black (the chapter is titled 'Members of your race are not admitted'), law school and the coining of the phrase Jane Crow, the Cold War years, the push toward 'an NAACP for women', and a late-life ordination. 494 pages with portraits.

Reviewed in The Journal of Southern History (2018).

Lightning Brown papers,

Brown, Lightning · 1983

Papers of Lightning Brown, a Chapel Hill activist for gay rights who was also the first openly gay person in North Carolina to run for public office. Most of the 1,500 items concern the 1984 elections: letters to and from public officials, articles and studies reflecting his work in the Democratic Party, on national legislation and on gay rights.

Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) Center of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill records, 1975-2014.

University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer (LGBTQ) Center · 1975

Records of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender, and Queer Center at UNC, 1975 to 2014, about 900 items in 2 linear feet, in the University Archives at UNC, collection 40433. Student groups represented include the Carolina Gay and Lesbian Association, B-GLAD, and the Women's Forum of the Association of Women Students, with student housing at Chapel Hill also covered.

UNC

William Ruthrauff Amberson papers, 1919-1968; 1971

Amberson, William Ruthrauff, 1894- · 1915

William Ruthrauff Amberson, born 1894, left papers spanning 1919 to 1968 with a small run from 1971. The papers concern the University of Tennessee at Memphis and southern farm politics: the Southern Tenant Farmers' Union, the Delta Cooperative Farm and Providence Plantation in Mississippi, the Socialist Party, and figures such as Norman Thomas, Howard Kester and Pauli Murray. Part of the Southern Historical Collection at UNC, collection 3862.

UNC

Michael R. Nelson papers, circa 1890-2012

Nelson, Michael R., 1963- · 1890

Roughly 2,000 items in 6.5 linear feet kept as the papers of Michael R. Nelson, born 1963, dated from about 1890 to 2012, collection 70140 in the Southern Historical Collection at UNC. Topics include politics and government in Carrboro, Chapel Hill and Orange County, campaign paraphernalia, and gay activists and politicians in North Carolina, naming Joseph A. Herzenberg, 1941 to 2007.

UNC

Joseph A. Herzenberg papers 1883-2006.

Herzenberg, Joseph A., 1941-2007 · 1883

Twenty linear feet of papers from Joseph A. Herzenberg, 1941 to 2007, about 2,500 items dated 1883 to 2006 in the Southern Historical Collection at UNC, collection 5367. Diaries are among the formats. The work describes a historian and political activist in Chapel Hill, campaign paraphernalia and Democratic Party politics, and gay activists and gay politicians in North Carolina.

UNC
Show 1 more

John Seelye papers,

Seelye, John · 1862

Papers of John Seelye (1931 to 2015), literary scholar and Penguin Classics editor, who taught American literature at Berkeley, Connecticut, UNC Chapel Hill, Dartmouth and Florida. The 26,100 items (46.7 linear feet) run from 1862 to 2015, mostly 1955 to 2007, in series of correspondence and contracts, academic files, research files, writings and personal papers, with Melville and Mark Twain among his subjects.

Research this storyline

Each dated event above names its source, the place to start. For finding more on an event across newspapers, records and histories, see the research guide Follow an event across several accounts. Ask at the North Carolina Room of the Orange County Public Library for help with local sources.

Cite or share

Friends of the Orange County Public Library. “On the Hill and the clubs that followed, 1989–1992.” Orange County Indexed, https://focplnc.org/orange-county-books/storylines/on-the-hill-storyline-1989/. Accessed October 22, 2026.

How to cite what you find

Suggest a correction or a source →

See these events in the full chronology All storylines

Two mice reading back to back against a leaf, with the hand-lettered words Friends of the Orange County Public Library
Illustration by Caldecott Medalist Matthew Cordell, gifted to the Friends 2026