Skip to content

Storyline · 1793–1828

The county court tries enslaved defendants, 1793–1828

Enslaved men accused of crimes in Orange County were tried at Hillsborough, first before a called court of justices and freeholders and later before juries in the county and Superior courts. Between 1793 and 1828 some were discharged when no one proved the charge and juries acquitted others of murder, while the court sentenced Bob to whipping, mutilation and branding, Joshua and Jim to hang, and Sam to branding under the benefit of clergy. In 1818 the court bound over Samuel Strudwick for the death of a woman he enslaved and had whipped.

1793–1828 Part of Slavery in Orange County 12 dated events

In November 1793 a called court of three justices and four freeholders met at Hillsborough to try Jack, a man enslaved by Absalom Tatom; no one appeared to present the charge, and he was discharged. In July 1794 Moses, enslaved by William Mangom, pleaded not guilty, no one proved the charge, and he was discharged on payment of costs and jail fees. On August 25, 1795 a jury of twelve heard Africa, enslaved by William Courtney, and Silvia testify for the State and found Isaac, enslaved by William Lytle, guilty on a charge the minutes do not name.

On August 31, 1798 the county court found Bob, enslaved by William Hunt of Granville County, guilty of breaking into Samuel Dick's house and sentenced him to thirty-nine lashes at the public whipping post, to have his ears nailed to the pillory and cut off, and to be branded on both cheeks, between noon and two o'clock that day. A jury acquitted Peter, held by Sarah Horton, of murder in February 1801. In February 1811 a jury of twelve freeholders who owned slaves convicted Joshua of murdering Abner Tapp, and the court sentenced him to hang on March 15. In May 1812 Sam, found guilty of grand larceny but not burglary, prayed the benefit of clergy, an old plea that spared some convicted people a death sentence, and was branded on the left thumb with the letter T in court. In August 1814 a jury acquitted Ned, held by Thomas Holloway, of murdering Robert Grisham. In May 1816 the court sentenced Jim, also called James, to hang for housebreaking and larceny; Thomas Snipes, who held him as William Ramsey's executor, had defended him, and the court granted their appeal.

In May 1818, told that Samuel Strudwick had whipped a woman he enslaved and that she afterwards died, the court, with Solicitor General Edward Jones's consent, bound him over to the next Superior Court to answer for killing her. That August it allowed coroner John Faddis five pounds for an inquest on the body of Bella, whom the minutes name as having been held by Strudwick. In 1828 the Superior Court convicted Jim, enslaved by Willie P. Mangum, of manslaughter in the death of another enslaved man and ordered 39 lashes; Sherod got 15 lashes for larceny, and Harry, sentenced to death for burglary, won a new trial on appeal.

Towns
Hillsborough
People with pages
3

The events, date by date

Every statement above comes from these dated entries in the chronology. Each links to its source.

  1. A called court discharges Jack, a man enslaved by Absalom Tatom, when no accuser appears A called court of three justices and four freeholders met to try Jack, a man held in slavery by Absalom Tatom. The sheriff called for the presentment, no one appeared, and Jack was discharged. People: Absalom Tatom Place: Hillsborough (called court) · Also named: JackMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: November Term 1793
  2. A called court discharges Moses, a man enslaved by William Mangom, when no one proves the charge At a court called in July 1794 to try Moses, a man held in slavery by William Mangom, Barnabas Burrows swore that notice of the trial had been given to Mangom. Moses pleaded not guilty; no one appeared to prove the charge, and he was discharged on payment of costs and jail fees. John Hogg acted as clerk in the clerk's absence. Place: Hillsborough (called court) · Also named: William Mangom, Barnabas Burrows, John Hogg, MosesMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: August Term 1794
  3. A jury convicts Isaac, a man enslaved by William Lytle, on a charge the minutes do not name In State v. Isaac, a man held in slavery by William Lytle, a jury of twelve heard Africa, a man enslaved by William Courtney, and Silvia, a woman enslaved by a man whose name the transcription leaves unclear, testify for the State, and found Isaac guilty as charged. The minutes do not give the charge or the sentence. People: William Courtney Place: Hillsborough (county court) · Also named: William Lytle, Africa, Isaac, SilviaMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: August Term 1795
  4. The court sentences Bob, an enslaved man, to whipping, mutilation and branding The county court found Bob, held in slavery by William Hunt of Granville County, guilty of breaking into Samuel Dick's house and taking goods. It sentenced him to thirty-nine lashes at the public whipping post, to have his ears nailed to the pillory and cut off, and to be branded on both cheeks, and ordered the sheriff to carry out the sentence between noon and two o'clock that day. Place: Hillsborough (public whipping post and pillory) · Also named: William Hunt, Samuel Dick, BobMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: August Term 1798
  5. A jury acquits Peter, an enslaved man, of murder Peter, held in slavery by Sarah Horton, was tried in the county court on an indictment for murder, pleaded not guilty, and was found not guilty by a jury of twelve. Place: Hillsborough (county court) · Also named: Sarah Horton, PeterMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: February Term 1801
  6. A jury of slaveholders convicts Joshua, an enslaved man, of murdering Abner Tapp The county court tried Joshua, an enslaved man, on an information charging him with the murder of Abner Tapp. A jury of twelve freeholders who owned slaves found him guilty, and the court sentenced him to be hanged on March 15, 1811, between ten and three o'clock, and ordered the sheriff to carry out the sentence. The next day the court gave Tapp's administrators leave to sell his perishable estate and an enslaved woman named Lydia to divide the estate. Place: Hillsborough · Also named: Abner Tapp, Joshua, LydiaMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: February Term 1811
  7. The court spares Sam, an enslaved man, from death under benefit of clergy and orders him branded Tried on an information for burglary, Sam, an enslaved man, was found not guilty of burglary but guilty of grand larceny. Asked why a death sentence should not be passed, he prayed the benefit of clergy, which the court allowed. It ordered him branded on the brawn of the left thumb with the letter T and held until costs were paid. The next day's minutes record that the sentence was carried out in court. Place: Hillsborough · Also named: SamMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: May Term 1812
  8. A jury acquits Ned, an enslaved man, of murdering Robert Grisham The court tried Ned, an enslaved man held by Thomas Holloway, on an indictment for the murder of Robert Grisham. After ordering witnesses for the state subpoenaed overnight, among them Samuel and Benjamin Peelor, Jeany Copley and Rachel Copley, it swore a jury that found Ned not guilty. Place: Hillsborough · Also named: Thomas Holloway, Robert Grisham, NedMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: August Term 1814
  9. The court sentences Jim, an enslaved man, to hang for housebreaking and grants his appeal The court convicted Jim, also called James, an enslaved man, of housebreaking, larceny and felony and sentenced him to be hanged on June 28, 1816, between noon and four o'clock. Thomas Snipes, who held Jim as executor of William Ramsey's will, had defended him; both Jim and Snipes prayed an appeal, which the court granted. During the case the court fined William Horner, a state witness who failed to appear, and jailed Burk Walker, charged as an accessory, until he gave security for his good behavior. Place: Hillsborough · Also named: Thomas Snipes, William Ramsey, Burk Walker, William HornerMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: May Term 1816
  10. The court binds Samuel Strudwick over to the Superior Court for the death of an enslaved woman he whipped Told that Samuel Strudwick had whipped one of the women he enslaved and that she afterwards died, the court, with the consent of Solicitor General Edward Jones, ordered a recognizance taken for Strudwick's appearance at the next Superior Court to answer for killing her. Paoli Ashe, Richard Ashe and John Taylor entered into the recognizance. Place: Hillsborough · Also named: Samuel Strudwick, Edward Jones, Paoli Ashe, Richard Ashe, John TaylorMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: May Term 1818
  11. The county pays the coroner for the inquest on Bella, held by Samuel Strudwick The court allowed coroner John Faddis five pounds for holding an inquest on the body of Bella, whom the minutes describe as late the property of Samuel Strudwick. The order was issued to Faddis on March 9, 1819. Place: Orange County · Also named: Samuel Strudwick, John Faddis, BellaMark Chilton, transcription of the Orange County Court of Pleas and Quarter Sessions minutes: August Term 1818
  12. Orange Superior Court tries Jim, Sherod and Harry, three enslaved men The 1828 term convicted Jim, held by Willie P. Mangum, of manslaughter in the death of another enslaved man and ordered 39 lashes. Sherod got 15 lashes for larceny, and Harry was sentenced to death for burglary but won a new trial on appeal. People: Willie P. Mangum Place: HillsboroughLefler and Wager, Orange County, 1752-1952 (1953), p. 100-101

People in this storyline

People with a page of their own whom the dated events above name, those named most often first.

Further reading

No indexed work is about this storyline itself yet. These are the most widely held histories of the theme it is filed under, so they may not discuss it. Follow a link to find a copy or view the material.

Background on Black Life & Civil Rights · the most widely held histories of the theme this storyline is filed under; they may not discuss it

To Free A Family

Nathans, Sydney · 2012 · Harvard University Press

Sydney Nathans's biography of Mary Walker, an enslaved woman from Orange County who escaped to the North in the mid nineteenth century and spent the following decades in Cambridge, Massachusetts, working to free the family she had left behind. Chapter titles trace her flight, her years among Northern friends, a rescue plot, a long silence, and the reunion that gives the book its close. Published 2012 by Harvard University Press, 330 pages with 20 pages of plates, illustrations and maps.

Reviewed in Choice Reviews Online (2012), Civil War Book Review (2012).

The Free Men

Ehle, Jr., John Marsden · 1965

John Ehle's account of the civil rights demonstrations in Chapel Hill in 1963 and 1964 and the young people who led them, first published by Harper & Row in 1965. This reprint from Lewisville, North Carolina adds an afterword by Wayne King. Civil rights and race relations in Chapel Hill are its subjects. 340 pages with illustrations and portraits.

To Drink from the Well: The Struggle for Racial Equality at the Nation’s Oldest University

Kapur, Geeta · 2021

Geeta Kapur's history of race at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, from the enslaved labor that built the campus through desegregation and the Black student protests that followed. Twelve chapters, with a foreword by William Barber II, move from the founding era and the Great Depression controversies to the state's response to integration and the turmoil of later decades; North Carolina Central University also figures. Published 2021 by Blair in Durham.

Frank Porter Graham and the 1950 Senate Race in North Carolina

Pleasants, Julian M.; Burns, Augustus M., III · 1990 · UNC Press

Julian M. Pleasants and Augustus M. Burns III on the 1950 Democratic Senate primary in North Carolina, in which Frank Porter Graham, the former president of the University of North Carolina, lost to Willis Smith after a campaign marked by race-baiting. Primaries, elections and race relations in the state are its subjects. Published by UNC Press in 1990, 356 pages with illustrations.

Reviewed in Choice Reviews Online (1991), The American Historical Review (1991), Journal of American History (1991), The Journal of Southern History (1992).

Ribbons of Color Along the Eno River

2021

Collected first-hand and second-hand stories from the Eno River valley as told from the standpoint of African Americans and Native people who have lived along the river in Orange and Durham counties, from prehistory to the present day. Issued by the Eno River Association in Durham as volume 10, number 2 of the Eno Journal, 2021, 106 pages with illustrations.

Show 6 more

The Impact of Slavery on the Education of Blacks in Orange County, North Carolina 1619-1970

Moore, Rosetta Austin · 2015

Rosetta Austin Moore's survey of Black education in Orange County from the colonial era to 1970, in a revised edition published in 2015 through Lulu in Morrisville. After chapters on slavery nationally and on schooling for enslaved people in North Carolina, the book turns to the county: its formation, the growth of its schools, the arrival of free public schooling for all, and the schools and African American educators of the twentieth century. 265 pages with maps, portraits and facsimiles.

A Mind to Stay: White Plantation, Black Homeland

Nathans, Sydney · 2017

Sydney Nathans's history of a Black community in Hale County, Alabama, whose founders were enslaved people sent there before the Civil War from the Cameron family's plantations in Orange County, North Carolina. Instead of following the Great Migration out of the South, this group stayed, moved from bondage to owning the land they had worked, and held onto it across generations. Published 2017, 342 pages with plates and maps; this is the e-book edition.

Reviewed in Journal of American History (2017), Journal of Social History (2017), London review of books (2017), The Journal of the Civil War Era (2018), The Journal of Southern History (2018), Environmental History (2018), ˜The œAlabama review (2019), The Oral History Review (2019), ˜The œRegister - Kentucky Historical Society/˜The œregister of the Kentucky Historical Society (2020).

African Americans of Durham and Orange counties : an oral history

Bolduc, Jean · 2016 · The History Press

Jean Bolduc's collection of oral history interviews with Black residents of Durham and Orange counties, published by The History Press in 2016, 125 pages with photographs and portraits. The narrators are the poet Jaki Shelton Green, civil rights lawyer Floyd McKissick, Walter Jackson, Nate Davis, Brenda Stephens, Diane Wright, Jackie Wagstaff and Michelle Johnson, and a closing chapter deals with the Ku Klux Klan. The interviews document Black life and race relations in the two counties across the twentieth century.

Sitting In and Speaking Out: Student Movements in the American South, 1960-1970

Turner, Jeffrey A. · 2010 · The University of Georgia Press

Jeffrey A. Turner's study of student activism on Southern campuses between 1960 and 1970, arguing that the region's own movement has been overshadowed by attention to national groups such as SDS. Nine chapters move from the 1960 sit-ins through white students and desegregation, the rise of student power, Black Power on Black and white campuses, and the war's effect on the region. Chapel Hill is among the campuses treated. Published 2010, 366 pages, online edition.

Reviewed in Choice Reviews Online (2011), Journal of American History (2012).

Rogers Road

Pearce, Emily Eidenier · 2009

Emily Eidenier Pearce's history of Rogers Road, the historically African American neighborhood on the edge of Chapel Hill and Carrboro, and of what happened to it after Orange County opened its landfill next door in 1972. Drawing on interviews with residents, the book records the neighborhood's origins, family life, churches and customs, and then the environmental and social burdens of decades beside the landfill. Privately issued in 2009, 298 pages with illustrations, maps and portraits.

A Traitor and a Scoundrel: Benjamin Hedrick and the Cost of Dissent

Smith, Michael Thomas · 2003 · University of Delaware Press ; London : Associated University Presses

Michael Thomas Smith's biography of Benjamin Sherwood Hedrick, the University of North Carolina chemistry professor dismissed in 1856 after he declared support for the antislavery presidential candidate John C. Fremont. Published by University of Delaware Press in 2003, 216 pages with illustrations. Topics include abolitionists and dissenters in North Carolina, the antislavery movement in the state, and the university's biography before 1962.

Reviewed in The Journal of Southern History (2005).

Research this storyline

Each dated event above names its source, the place to start. For finding more on an event across newspapers, records and histories, see the research guide Follow an event across several accounts. Ask at the North Carolina Room of the Orange County Public Library for help with local sources.

Cite or share

Friends of the Orange County Public Library. “The county court tries enslaved defendants, 1793–1828.” Orange County Indexed, https://focplnc.org/orange-county-books/storylines/enslaved-defendants-storyline-1793/. Accessed October 22, 2026.

How to cite what you find

Suggest a correction or a source →

See these events in the full chronology All storylines

Two mice reading back to back against a leaf, with the hand-lettered words Friends of the Orange County Public Library
Illustration by Caldecott Medalist Matthew Cordell, gifted to the Friends 2026